Skip to main content

Blu-ray vs. HD-DVD

I'm an early adopter (My wife would say, "Gadget geek"). As such, I've been burned a few times (MiniDisc, Atari Lynx, ReplayTV, DAT), but have also been on the cutting edge of a lot of cool new technology.

I am also an avid film enthusiast. I love DVD and even went so far as to eBay a laserdisc player for some stuff that was (and is) only available in that format. As HD content was set to debut, I knew I would be on board, and when the next gen gaming systems came out, blu-ray support clinched the deal for a PS3.

Through all the rabid, fanboy flamewars on hidefdigest, aintitcool and others, my satisfaction in my choice has steadily grown. Here's why:
  1. HD-DVD and Blu-ray offer IDENTICAL picture/sound quality on go-forward releases (VC-1 and TrueHD). I am astounded at how gorgeous the pictures are. Simply stunning.
  2. Blu-ray has the edge in studio support. Universal's HD-DVD-only stance hurts, but blu-ray has Fox, Disney, MGM and of course, Sony/Columbia as blu-exclusives. That's no contest.
  3. New releases will count FAR more than catalog sales save a HANDFUL of blockbuster titles BECAUSE:
  4. Upscaling makes HD "repurchasing" a tougher sell AND
  5. Newer movies benefit from the crystal clean film assets that really shine in HD.

Of course, there are some epic movies (Lawrence of Arabia, Ten Commandments, etc.) that will really look astounding in HD. But are you REALLY sweating to get an HD transfer of "Scary Movie"? I'll pass.

On the other hand, thanks to my PS3, projector and 92" screen, the wife and I are already deciding which NEW movies will end up as strictly home vs. theatrical viewings: FF:Silver Surfer (Fox release=Blu-ray purchase); Transformers (Dreamworks/Paramount=movie and home purchase); Evan Almighty (Universal=maybe a DVD rental).

With two kiddies, most family movie choices (Pixar/Disney's included) are going to be seen on the home cineplex too. Factor in babysitters, snacks and gas and the economics of HD start to look a LOT more favorable. Easily, $70+ per film in L.A. for a family of four.

Blu-ray's studio support guarantees a stronger stream of FUTURE releases as well as some incredible catalog properties already mentioned here... Blockbuster's Blu-ray "exclusive" announcement makes them the first and largest brick and mortar retailer to declare for one format... Things are trending toward Sony, IMO.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Two Parties are NOT the same.

Thinking about the differences between the Dems and the Trump. Trump is promising "America First" jingoism without delivering anything but racism, while riding the economic tide of his predecessor. Consider what the Dems have been DEMANDED to fix. 1) Healthcare for all Americans 2) Student loan relief 3) A workable immigration solution 4) $15 min. wage and/or guaranteed income 5) Incremental gun regulation 6) Protecting the environment 7) Iran nuclear treaty 8) Thwarting Russian election interference 9) Reparations 10) Lowering taxes for middle class 11) Raising taxes for the 1% 12) Improving K-12 education 13) Rolling back Citizens United 14) Protecting Roe v. Wade 15) A satisfying DC Cinematic Universe (why not?) It's perfectly fine to be in your feelings if you are upset that this country is so f*cked that your particular issue is not being trumpeted by all (or any) of the Democratic primary candidates. It's even OK if you feel that the cur...
1 comment
Read more

Ashley Todd

Y'all know the story by now. White, female McCain phonebanker, Ashley Todd, leaves Texas to venture North to support her candidate. After a stint in New York, she ends up in Pittsburgh until Thursday, when she lost her effing mind and became Susan Smith Part Deux . The McCain campaign can hardly be blamed for this girl's actions. However, they need to be questioned on their response. Within hours of the incendiary allegations, two things happened. McCain and Palin called Ashley Todd. A press flack from McCain's Pennsylvania operation started pushing the story and adding salacious details. Consider what was at stake here. In a campaign environment already marked with strained racial tensions, Todd's story was potenitally explosive. It would have made a lot more sense to issue a generic statement (like Obama's campaign did). Instead, McCain and Palin lent legitimacy to the allegations (at least for a few hours) by calling her. They vetted Todd's story abou...
Post a Comment
Read more

After Birth of a Nation

So I finally paid to watch BOAN. I can now offer my commentary without being a hypocrite. Full disclosure... After watching the movie, I reread the ACTUAL "Confessions of Nat Turner" (not the Styron novel) to make sure I wasn't trippin'. Before you comment on anything I have to say, please confirm that you have done the same. This movie was over-hyped. It was a ambitious effort at telling an overlooked story. It did have some compelling moments. However, the idea that this is an important film because it tells the ACCURATE story of Turner's revolt is diminished by the innumerable instances of artistic license and outright misrepresentation of facts. A "Based on a true story" title card doesn't mean you get to play Law & Order SVU with the historical record to the extent that you actually twist Turner into something he wasn't. To be clear, there is precious little in the historical record of Turner's life. Consequently, one might argu...
Post a Comment
Read more